| 1988-89 (unseeded) Kansas City, MO |
| win 68-65 over #5 Wingate College (N.C) |
| lost 69-90 to #4 St. Ambrose University (IA) |
| |
| 1991-92 (unseeded) Jackson, TN |
| win 79-72 over Campbellville University (KY) |
| lost 55-83 to #3 Southwest Oklahoma St. |
| |
| 1994-95 (#4 seed) Monmouth, OR |
| win 100-90 over St. Francis University (IN) |
| lost 74-79 to Bethany (KS) |
| |
| 1995-96 (#2 seed) Angola, IN |
| win 101-52 over Westbrook College (ME) |
| win 79-68 over Georgetown College (KY) |
| win 79-62 over #7 St. Ambrose University (IA) |
| lost 75-77 to Huron University (SD) |
| |
| 1996-97 (#10 seed) Sioux City, IA |
| win 79-74 over Benedictine College (KS) |
| win 77-72 in OT over #7 Sterling College (KS) |
| win 80-76 over #2 Briar Cliff College (IA) |
| lost 80-86 to Northwest Nazarene University (ID) |
| |
| 1997-98 (#10 seed) Sioux City, IA |
| win 71-62 over Pacific Lutheran University (WA) |
| win 71-56 over Taylor University (IN) |
| win 87-82 over #15 Central Methodist University (MO) |
| lost 60-73 to Walsh University (OH) |
| |
| 1998-99 (#12 seed) Sioux City, IA |
| win 81-58 over Indiana Southeast University |
| loss 73-81 to Briar Cliff College (IA) |
| |
| 2004-05 (#3 seed/quarter 4) Sioux City, IA |
| win 70-65 over #24 Bryan College (Tenn.) |
| loss 51-66 to #7 Evangel University (Mo.) |
| |
| 2005-06 (#3 seed/quarter 4) Sioux City, IA |
| win 50-40 over Ottawa University (Kan.) |
| lost 55-56 to #12 Benedictine College (Kan.) |